Meta has been fined €805 million by Italy’s data protection authority for using the gallery suggestions feature on Facebook, which was activated by default, to access users’ images, videos and metadata.
The Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante) has told Meta to remove the feature from being active by default. This means that it will need to ensure the feature does not appear as an active option for users who have previously allowed access to their phone galleries. It will also need to make sure that the feature cannot be used without an additional opt-in, with clear information about what the feature does and how to turn it off.
During the investigation it was discovered Facebook had used a blanket permission to give access to multiple functions within the app. There was no clear explanation to users that the permission would allow the app to suggest photos and videos from their private galleries.
Once users had given the permission Facebook could gain access to a whole photo album. The authority said it was difficult to know exactly what information the application was gaining access to.
Garante concluded that this breached Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code. This article was introduced to bring the ePrivacy Directive of the European Union into national law. It means that any information stored on users’ devices as part of their private life must be given free and informed consent before applications are allowed to access it.
Meta has appealed the fine. A spokesperson said the fine was unfair as the feature cannot be used unless users have allowed it in their device settings. They added that users can revoke or change their permission at any time.
The authority has also told Meta that it must provide an initial report on how it will comply with the ruling within 30 days and a final report within 90 days. If they fail to comply within the 60-day timeframe then the feature cannot be active for users who haven’t given valid consent.
This comes after a complaint from consumer protection organisation Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti in Bolzano. In July 2025, they advised users of Facebook to turn off the gallery suggestions and check the app’s permissions.
The investigation did not look into whether the content from Facebook’s galleries were used to train AI models. Meta has denied this.
However, Garante may investigate whether the new feature introduced this year, which allows processing of gallery content in the cloud, has breached any rules.
Meta had claimed that the Irish data protection regulator should be responsible for this issue. However, this was rejected by Garante as the ePrivacy framework does not use the EU’s one stop shop system.
The feature has been active since 2023 and the investigation started in July 2025.
The fine of €805 million equates to around 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide revenue. The authority took into consideration the potential impact on around 20 million Android users in Italy, how long the breach had been occurring, a previous ruling in 2019 against Meta and Meta’s lack of cooperation. However, they also took into consideration that Meta had made changes following the complaint. Regulators felt these changes were late and not enough.
Read the original article:
Meta Fined €805 Million in Italy Over Facebook’s Access to Android Photo Galleries Without Consent
